Ballistic Nylon or Poly Tarpaulin - Which is Best for Hockey Bags?

When comparing 820D poly tarpaulin to 1000D ballistic nylon, it's essential to consider the specific properties and characteristics that make each material suitable for different applications. While 1000D ballistic nylon is known for its strength and durability, 820D poly tarpaulin has several advantages that make it superior in certain contexts, particularly for products like bags and protective gear. Here’s why:

Water Resistance

820D Poly Tarpaulin

This material is often treated or inherently constructed to be waterproof or highly water-resistant. It is designed to repel water, making it ideal for use in environments where exposure to moisture is a concern. The waterproof qualities ensure that the contents of a bag or cover remain dry even in heavy rain or when placed on wet surfaces.

1000D Ballistic Nylon

While ballistic nylon is strong and durable, it is not naturally waterproof. It can be coated with a water-resistant finish, but this can wear off over time, requiring reapplication. Without this treatment, nylon tends to absorb moisture, which can compromise the protection it offers.

Weight

820D Poly Tarpaulin

Poly tarpaulin tends to be lighter than 1000D ballistic nylon, even at similar thicknesses. This makes it an excellent choice for applications where weight is a critical factor, such as in bags or covers that need to be portable and easy to carry.

1000D Ballistic Nylon

While ballistic nylon is known for its durability, it is heavier than poly tarpaulin. The added weight can be a disadvantage in products where mobility and ease of use are essential.

Durability and Tear Resistance

820D Poly Tarpaulin

Poly tarpaulin is engineered to be highly tear-resistant. Its composition and structure make it less prone to ripping under stress, which is crucial for maintaining the integrity of the material over time, especially in rough conditions.

1000D Ballistic Nylon

Ballistic nylon is incredibly strong and was originally designed for military applications to resist shrapnel and fragmentation. However, it is prone to fraying and can unravel if punctured or cut, especially along the edges.

Ease of Maintenance

820D Poly Tarpaulin

This material is easier to clean and maintain. Its water-resistant surface allows for quick wiping to remove dirt, grime, or spills, making it more suitable for environments where cleanliness is essential.

1000D Ballistic Nylon

Nylon can be more challenging to clean, especially if it absorbs liquids or gets stained. It may require more intensive cleaning methods, which can potentially degrade the material over time.

Conclusion

While 1000D ballistic nylon is known for its exceptional strength and durability, 820D poly tarpaulin offers several advantages that make it superior for specific applications, particularly in scenarios requiring waterproofing, lighter weight, tear resistance, and ease of maintenance. Depending on the intended use, 820D poly tarpaulin can provide a better balance of performance, cost, and practicality, making it an excellent choice for products like high-quality bags, covers, and protective gear.